DECLINED - App: GreenMan3 - by GM Fright

[GreenMan3]

The application submitted by GreenMan3 is as follows:

[Masticrom]

I'd love to do another instance with you to see how you've improved

[GreenMan3]

Great!. I will only be on a bit in the morning (Sunday, July 4) because of family stuff in the afternoon, but if you can give me an idea when to catch you online Monday or Tuesday, we can set up that random.

Thanks,

GreenMan

[Reji]

This app is sexy

[Poupalos]

I just want to point out a few things.

After reading this re app, it gives me the impression that we have had many conversation since your first app failed.

I only spoke to you once and that was when I told you to re app as the guild is in need of a Ele Shaman now. I never once stated that your talent build " was good or bad" and if you copied my build that is not entirely a "approval"

Your gear score may have increased with some upgrades but how goes your raid awareness?

[GreenMan3]

I did not mean to imply that we had had several conversations. We did not. As you have pointed out we had that one conversation where you suggested that I reapply.

As to the talent build, earlier you had commented that your talent build was the best, and after close examining it and realizing the differences from mine (and recognizing how your differences were better in a raid environment) I implements the 2 differences (or maybe 3) that made our talent builds identical. Since you had commented that yours was the best and now mine matched yours, I would have thought you would have approved. I apologize for putting words in your mouth.

As to my my awareness, I have changed my UI layout so that I have a better view if the fighting field and I am not having to flick my eyes all over the screen to get the basic stats (health, targeted mob, totems, spell cooldowns, etc... ). So my awareness has improved (in my opinion).

[GM Fright]

Horatio,
Thanks for your continued interest in the guild. I would like to give our members and officers a chance to evaluate what changes may have been made in your play style, ability, and gear since your last application.

As you were very recently denied, please don't be surprised by any skepticism or by our candor in evaluating your application. We might be recruiting an elemental shaman, but that does not lower our standards.

I look forward to hearing some feedback from our members and officers about your improvements.

-Fright

[GreenMan3]

GM Fright wrote:

Horatio, Thanks for your continued interest in the guild. I would like to give our members and officers a chance to evaluate what changes may have been made in your play style, ability, and gear since your last application. As you were very recently denied, please don't be surprised by any skepticism or by our candor in evaluating your application. We might be recruiting an elemental shaman, but that does not lower our standards. I look forward to hearing some feedback from our members and officers about your improvements. -Fright

I understand completely and expect no less. I REALLY am looking for a quality guild with high standards.

Thanks,

Greenman/Horatio

[GM Fright]

Horatio,

Thanks again for your application... Again.

Unfortunately I don't think you yet fit the bill for what we're looking for. I do still hope you're able to find a raiding home where you can be successful.

Good luck.
-Fright